Ang Lee has reason
to be happy. This past weekend he won the Directors' Guild of America award
for Best Director for his film Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon. The film
is nominated for the top prizes, including Best Director, Best Picture, and
Best Foreign Film. Since 1953 only four directors who won the DGA honor did
not also win the Oscar for Best Director. In other words, the DGA award is a
good omen for his fate Oscar
night.
Ang Lee has come
a long way since Cannes,
where his film Crouching
Tiger, Hidden Dragon premiered out of competition. Since then it has
accumulated awards from festivals around the world, as well as enthusiastic
reactions from both critics and audiences.
Ang Lee showed
up serene and relaxed in Zurich for the European publicity tour. This Swiss
city isn't typically an obligatory stop on the publicity circuit, but Lee was
anxious to catch up with some old friends here. FilmFestivals.com caught up
with him in Switzerland.
Christophe Pinol: Did you have any particular classic Hong Kong films in
mind during the production of your film?
Ang Lee: I don't think that the genre influenced me, but rather that certain
scenes from films influenced me. I like to extract the spirit of certain classic
ideas and apply them to my films. But popular influences also inspired me, and
I try to bring something new into the clichés of certain situations I grew up
with. Over time, old martial arts film schools closed and choreographers have
revived the genre. They have honed their skills over the course of years, and
they can create scenes that are more and more incredible. It evolved so that
it was only important to film this type of scene. The genre had slowly transformed
into something very oriented to the action side, and sequences simply followed
each other with little regard to what fell between two action scenes. With Crouching
Tiger, I tried to return to a quality of script that was found in classic
films, all the while creating exceptional action scenes.
CP: How did you come up with the incredible action scenes? Did you have a precise
image in mind before filming?
AL: I had many images in my head but I didn't know how to use them. During the
filing it's true that we would spend half a day on a very difficult scene when
we should have been moving on to other things. I did suggest the idea of the
combat scenes. The one with the chase over rooftops, the one between Michelle
Yeoh and Zhang Ziyi, the one on treetops … But the choreography itself had to
be created and it Yuen Woo Ping (who also choreographed The Matrix, ed.)
who deserves all the credit.
We tried to make
it so that the battles represent the premise of the development of each of the
characters and their histories. And then I was helped enormously by specialists,
particularly on the cameras by the cinematographer (Peter Pau, nominated for
this year's Oscar for Best Cinematography). Sometimes he would say to me, "No,
it would be better with the camera here." He's someone with a lot of experience.
Together we would see what would work well for the action and if it wasn't compatible
with my ideas as a director, I would ask him to find something else. They are
more talented than Americans.
So it was a genuine
collaboration during which I learned that real kung-fu has very little to do
with what is seen in movies. It must come from dance, taking into account how
it is filmed, the skill of the actors… I even had to train myself and hire a
coach to teach me the basic elements and to try and understand what I was confronted
by.
CP: Do you risk altering your approach to direction because of what you have
learned?
AL: Yes, I think so. Sometimes directors-like myself and many others-have so
much to say but we don't really know how to express ourselves. I learned enormously
there through contact with the group. We achieved magnificent results even while
working very quickly, and certainly less expensively than in Hollywood. They
are very clever, fast and efficient.
CP: The film has now opened in Asia. How has the public reacted?
AL: I was very nervous about their reaction, but it's all turned out fine. They
have definitely liked the action scenes, but it's true that I know that all
of the nuances of the plot would be especially appreciated by Western audiences.
Films of this genre became so plundered by Asian directors-sometimes one has
the impression of a sort of rape-that the action scenes in Crouching
Tiger brought back old memories.
CP: Did you cast Zhang Ziyi mainly because she is a dancer with the Chinese
Opera?
AL: But you know, Michelle Yeoh danced with them too! It's true that the choreography
we used has a lot in common with the Chinese Opera. It is a school with a very
musical and emotional background when it comes to movement. That's also why
there are a lot of dancers in cinematography. They're very agile, very flexible…
And for a lead actress, we had a better chance of finding a beautiful woman
who is a dancer, because in the martial arts, the women are more: "Grrrhhh"
(Ang Lee makes a face, raises his hands to his face, showing his claws, ed.).
But dancers aren't as strong as martial artists. Martial artists are more focused
on force whereas dancers focus on flexibility and agility. They have had to
adapt. The punches they throw are very different. Sometimes we had difficult
moments. But the skills of the actors help as well. That's why more artists
come from the Chinese Opera than from martial arts schools.
CP: Every film
you make is so different from the previous film. Why do you choose to work like
this?
AL: Very simply,
it's because when I finish a film, I need something new. If I know full well
where I am going, there is no adventure, no shiver. And also I would be afraid
or repeating myself. So for as long as I can continue working this way, I will.